The Founding of Elba

This plaque, embedded in indiginous rock, sits in the center of town.
 

From Uncharted Frontier land...

In 1798, Joseph Ellicott, an experienced surveyor representing the Holland Land Company, came into the area with men and equipment to survey the vast tract of land and laid it out into townships and ranges. When the trees and brush had been cleared to a width of four rods from the Pennsylvania border north to Lake Ontario so that an unobstructed view of the sky could be obtained, actual surveying of the huge plot into townships carried westward and included what were to become the eight counties west of the Genesee River.

Mr. Ellicott estimated the wages needed for six months were $19,830 and an additional $7,356 for the cost of equipment, which did not include the necessary funds for transportation nor for "wine, spirits, brandy and medicine."

Handbills had been circulated throughout the east, informing hopeful settlers of the advantages of the region: namely the rich soil, moderate climate and forests to supply building materials. Between this method of advertising and the stories brought back by the soldiers of the Revolutionary War, who had seen the land for themselves, a westward movement was started.

Joseph Ellicott's Quaker upbringing of propriety and honor, industry and thoroughness fitted him for the task. He would often discard his ruffled sleeves and waist coat, the height of fashion for the day, to don the buckskin of the frontiersman to help erect a sawmill or any other building to help promote the comfort of the settlers. It was Joseph Ellicott who was responsible for the road being laid out from Batavia north to Pine Hill or "The Pinery" as it was called in 1802. The Indians referred to it as Te-ca-so-a-a, "Pine Lying Up."

The Town of Elba is Born

Genesee County passed new legislation in 1820, creating the towns of Elba, Byron and Stafford from the original Town of Batavia. Appointed that year were town officials and 18 pathmasters - people who were responsible for keeping the roads in good condition.

At a special meeting on June 19, it was voted to raise the money for a school, to provide $25 for the support of the poor, to procure a ledger book for the Clerk and for the Supervisor to audit the book. On July 1, a Jury list of 117 eligible men was recorded.

Pine Hill Incorporates

In October of 1882, a spirited movement was being made to incorporate the village to be known as Pine Hill. A census was taken, revealing that 397 persons were living within the proposed limits of the incorporation. A committee of five was appointed to procure a survey and map of the area.

It was required that there be 300 inhabitants for each square mile of territory proposed to be included within the incorporated limits. The promoters of incorporation wanted to include the West Shore railroad. In doing so, a number of large and valuable farms had to be included. The owners objected for the increase in taxes that would result. Their argument: that the entire village of Pine Hill included 300 people on 1/4 square mile. The other square mile to be included contained less than 100 people.

They sought to defeat the measure at the election, but were unsuccessful, so they took the matter to court. An appeal was filed, specifying irregularities in the election and claiming that the proceedings were entirely illegal because various bureaucratic procedures were not followed. Judge Bangs rendered his decision on December 28, 1882, as follows: "I hereby adjudge that the said election so appealed form is illegal by reason that there is not the requisite population reside within the territory embraced in the proposed village to authorize such election to be held." He referred to the extra land, which did not contain 300 persons.

In October 1883, a decision was handed down in Rochester declaring the election of the taxpayers to incorporate illegal. Much hostility and resentment had formed amongst the people involved. The new atmosphere threatened changes in social and business relations, the withdrawing of trade and patronage, the settling of old accounts and even the threat of foreclosure. It created strife and division among neighbors and long-time friends, effecting the churches, schools and even families.

On April 14, 1884, a new vote was taken and resulted in a majority in favor, naming the Village "Elba." In celebrating the event, disgraceful behavior was indulged. Probably never in the history of the town was there such a shameful disregard for propriety. "Boys and men with a full three sheets to the wind tramped the streets in the night, howling and singing in wild and gibberish strains; [Elba's only] cannon was placed in front of the dwellings of men who did not favor the movement to incorporate, and heaving charges, fired, breaking windows, glass doors, etc." But to unburden them of such dishonor, early the next day parties were sent out to repair the damages. On May 15, 1884, a meeting was held at Hundredmark's Hall, and the first Village Officers were selected.

[Previous Page] [Next Page]


Navigational Map

Map of Elba

Places to visit:

  1. Village Limits
  2. Elba Grange
  3. A.A. Grinnell's Lumber

General Information:


Page Prepared 4 October 1996 by Envision Computer Services, and Town & Village Historian Scott Benz. Questions? Problems? email: cole@iinc.com

Thanks for stopping by!